Wednesday, November 10, 2010

Group members:
Tyler Toussaint
PG Santiago
Richie Black
Robby Doyle


Polling questions

1. How important is education to you?
a. Important
b. Somewhat Important
c. Not important

2. Should education be a main political issue in politics in America today?
a. Yes
b. No

3. Do you think schools in Arizona receive enough funding?
a. Yes
b. No
c. Not Sure

4. To increase education funding, money should be cut from:
a. Nowhere
b. Border Security
c. Infrastructure
d. Public Services
e. Social Services

















Most students picked "A" for question 1, which was that education is very important to them. For Question 2, about twice as many students thought that education should be a main political issue in politics today. Question 3, most students put either yes or no, but a little more put no. This shows that students are informed, or at least






















The main difference between Honors students and General Education students is that the Honors students took their education much more seriously. Although there weren't any students that said education was not important to them, more general education students said that it was "somewhat important," while almost all honors students said that it was "very important." There were more general education students than honors students that thought education should not be a main political issue, but the majority of both groups thought that it should be. More general education students think that Arizona schools need more funding, and more honors students believed that our schools receive enough funding. The majority of both groups think that funding should be cut from border security and put into education.





Question 1, Grade Level




Question 2, Grade Level






Question 3, Grade Level






Question 4, Grade Level, Answers A-D






Question 4, Grade Level, Answer E







While most of the results we obtained is fairly random, I did notice some trends within our questions, especially question 1 and 4. Question 1 had the mostly the same results across all the grade levels, the majority of people said that education was important to them, with that option always leading ahead of “somewhat important” and not important at all. This shows that despite what grade you’re in, education is either important or somewhat important, with very little not caring about it at all. Question 2 is a different story, with all the grade levels having similar results, except for grade 10. Grade 10 most likely so different from the rest because perhaps the people we chose are uninformed, or just plain had no idea, resulting in them to vote “no”, but it’s impossible to tell without actually going back and asking the sophomores why they voted that way.


Question 3 differed quite a lot, as people appear to be split on the matter of whether or not Arizona schools receive enough funding, in general freshmen believe they do not, same with the sophomores and senior crowd, but the juniors resulted showed that they believe they do receive enough funding. Similar to the analysis of question 2, the same sophomore crowd may be uninterested or under-informed regarding just how much funding the school receives. Based on how many people answered “not sure”, I’d say that each grade level has it’s share of uninformed people, and perhaps this is caused by the general lack of information that is being provided. Question 4 also has very similar results across all grade levels, and that is that money should be cut from border security to better finance education, with only a few from each level choosing the other options.


The differences between each grade level are hard to find, as most of the questions had generally the same results in the polls, meaning that I don’t think grade level generally has a strong impact on people’s opinion, as long as you are informed, you are able to make a decision despite what grade you are in. After saying this though, I think the reason of the often different sophomore choices are due to the lack of information, as you don’t really get taught anything about the financial situation of schools, all of the information is gained through personal experiences, and other political socialization methods, such as family, media, etc.









As we can see from questions 1 and 2, we can infer that both the boys and girls care about their education. from the region we live in, the parents of these childeren probably tell them to go and seek an education an have the word drilled into their head, which is good. Surveying childeren from a high school in a nice, middle to high class families, gated community, childeren from this area we see education as a strong key to sucess.
Now, Question 3 shows us some differences in women and men. For women, the majority claim to notice a lack of funding in their school. While the majority of men thought funding us enough to keep schools educating childeren at a high level. Here, many factors can be considered. Boys for example, have a tendency of caring soley for the ones around them and for themsleves.. this can lead to the things they have in front of them are the only things they can use and make the best out of it. if they are getting good grades, or for some not, they dont matter if the book is half ripped, or from a second grade class. Wmoen on the otherhand, care alot about the people around them, its just the way it is. this will cause women to look around them and see the lack funds effecting everyone in not just school but the whole country.. if someone somewhere is getting a lack of education, they will state funds in Arizona are not cut up to what it use to be. they are going to care about the good of everyone, and men will too, just not as high as girls.
Lastly, Question 4 tells alot of how region effects people decisions. Of question 4, the majority would cut border security on the girls side as well as that of the girls.. Now, why would kids from a high school in a border state near mexico, A country which illegal immigrant flow on a daily basis, say cut the spendings?Kids, can see the main issues in front of them but mostly not understand them fully. They think the best way is too cut spendings because it's to the point of madness. Do they know why? that would be a whole other survey.. but, we can see from both genders that influence on state issues can lead to an opinion. Boys probably picked border security frequently as an answer becasue they could think a much more forceful way of solving the problem... that what boys do. Girls voted as a majority for border security but not by much. most believed that it shold be where it is.. no cuts and infrastructure also made near the majority. Girls porbably mixed their areas which fundings should be cut becuase they see issues more as a spectrum and not to one issue..girls lean more to the liberal way of thinking while men lean to the conservative side.. which we can see form the conclusions to question 4's polling.
In conclusion, Men and Women often see things differently, when it comes to political stands, becuase men and women have complete different mindsets. one cares for all , while one cares for some. (Women, Men). the way men's and women's minds were set up from the day they were created can stretch to what we are looking at as a whole.. the way they respond to questions in a political issues such as educational reform.


Randomness was an important part while conducting our polling, as each of generally chose any student that we could find at four main locations, on the campus in the morning before school started, at both of the lunches, and in the library after school, and once before school. Our choices of who to poll were completely random, there was no one thing that made us choose a group of students over another group. We made sure to not poll the same person twice, and we often times tried to avoid people we knew in hopes of finding a random person who we know nothing about, and we were actually pretty successful in doing this. I feel like our group did a great job in keeping things random while choosing who to poll, and it paid off by getting a diverse amount of results and students in the mix.





































































































































































































19 comments:

  1. Your poll looks pretty good, and it seemed to turn out how I would expect it. More students would say that they care about their education than not. However, it does look like you guys approached more males than you did females, especially if you look at your results, considering males got more total votes on every question. Maybe it had something to do with your group being comprised solely of males?

    It also appears that you polled more Honors students than Gen Ed students, but I'm not really surprised by that. Many students in our school are in AT LEAST one Honors class if not more.

    Overall it looks like you guys did a great job. Nice analysis, by the way.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey guys! Great job with this first of all. I had a couple ideas about some of the strange results that you guys got that might make sense as to why certain people voted the way they did.

    You said that Juniors voted that they believe that schools do recieve sufficient funding while the other grade levels voted that schools did. Well, I remember last year in English, Mrs. McDermott went on a rampage on how schools could have enough money if they only spent it the right ways. She mentioned for example that we spend thousands of dollars on graduation at Cardinal's Stadium and how that money could be used in a plethora of other useful ways. Depending on how many students have her as a teacher (which plenty of the ones you probably polled DO), or another teacher who strongly voices their opinion, they could possibly form their opinion around what their teachers say. I knhow that My junior year is when I became really informed about school spending and if it had been me last year voting, I probably would have voted the same way.

    I also found it interesting that the majority of people voted that they would take money away from Border Patrol over any other area to give more funding to schools. It has seemed like a pattern at this school, from who I talk to and what I hear, that people Want a lot of money spent on border patrol because they are tired of illegal immigration. It's possible some just believe that we are spending too Much on it, or that they realize that the other areas like infrastructure or public services are areas that are supplying people with jobs and are important for Arizona's economy.

    I hope these ideas offered some clarity on those fuzzy areas of data, but otherwise these results are pretty standard to what I expected they would be. Obviously more honors kids consider their education important and of course most believe it should be a major political issue right now due to all the media hype about it recently, ect. Nice Job!

    ReplyDelete
  3. What surprises me the most is that some students actually thought schooling and education had enough funding in your question number 3. I totally thought that that would have been a biased question especially when polling at school. I figured everyone would have said that schools dont receive enough money with how much teachers talk about it and with all the cuts and stuff like that.

    Also on question number 1 with the comparision of male vs female i noticed that men cared more about schooling than girls. That strikes me as odd because i guess theres that common misconception that girls care more than boys about school. haha. But that could have3 also have been just like Driscoll said, that you may have polled more boys than girls.

    But anyway... Great job guys! especially with the shortened time you guys were given!

    ReplyDelete
  4. For question 4 I think an option should have been "Other" instead of "Nowhere". The reason for this would be because the options sort of limit the interviewee.
    As far as the honors graphs go the correlation makes sense due to students who take honors classes clearly value education more.
    I find it interesting however that honors students believe that there is enough funding for education and general education students do not. If this is the case than it clearly contradicts my previous statement on how honors students value education more than the latter. Perhaps honors students believe that they have everything they need to be successful whereas general education students believe that they need more materials and assistance to succeed.

    ReplyDelete
  5. You guys did a very good job on your poll and for the most part it all makes complete sense. When it comes to the honors kids, it makes sense that most of them would say that they care about their education more than the general education students. I found it interesting that all of the honors kids thought we have enough money in our school’s budget but the general education students thought we did not. It would seem that the honors students would want more money so that they could improve their education more, where as the general education students you would think, that if they are not concerned with their education as much, they would not care about the amount of money the school is getting.

    As for women and men, I find it interesting that women feel schools need more funding but men do not see it as a necessity. When you say that men are selfish and really only care about themselves, wouldn’t they want more money for their schools so that they can be more successful? Both men and women obviously care about their education as shown through questions 1 and 2 so it makes sense that women and men should want more funding for their schools so they can get more text books, new computers, etc.

    Living in Arizona and what with all of the problems taking place on the border, it makes sense that students think that more money should come from Border Patrol than any other area. Perhaps students feel that too much money is going into paying the National Guard to come down to the border and prevent illegals from entering. It may depend on their views of immigration as to whether or not too much money is being put into border patrol and not enough money is being put into other things.

    Good job!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Such boring graphs, but in the little time you guys had to do it, kudos to you. :) Well sorry that I dont write so much crap explaining, analyzing and asking questions about your poll. I was actually one of your voters. Remember that warm sunny day in the library last week? Yeah, that was me. The mexican. You can tell that these were Arizonians that you polled because of that whole funding is not enough and funds should be cut from boarder security thing. I'm surprised that the only significant cleavage was between boys and girls. I just guess are smarter and know what's up.
    P.S. My favorite part was scrolling all the way down to get to the comments.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I thought it definitely made sense that honors students cared more about education than general ed., and that they believed education should be a big part of politics. However, on question three when a majority of the honors kids thought that we do have enough funding for education...i thought this was odd, considering a majority of our teachers have definitely made it a point that we don't have a lot of funding (pay cuts, bigger class sizes, teachers cut, etc). Maybe it's because honors kids aren't affected as much as general ed? I'm pretty curious about that.
    Another thing i thought was strange was that tenth graders thought that education should not be a major issue in politics. I can't really think of an explanation for that. And also, the results regarding where funding needs to be cut, i think it makes sense that a lot of people said border patrol. It shows that a lot of students don't support excess spending on it. Another factor could be that we do have a lot of hispanic/mexican students (i could be way off i have no idea) and maybe a lot of them support illegal immigration?

    ReplyDelete
  8. I am very suprised that some students voted that schools recieved too much funding. Being a student, you would think that they would want more tax dollars to contributed to their school so that they would be able to do any activity they pleased(sports and clubs). I was also suprised that students believd border patrol should be cut to increase educational funding. You would think that living in Arizona would increase their desire for a stronger border patrol.
    It made sense that honors students cared about recieving an education while Gen ed students dgaf.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Your poll seemed effective and student-friendly, with straightforward, insightful questions. I also find it interesting that most students would want border control cut to give more money to schools. Arizona is a very conservative state, which would theoretically mean that Arizona students would advocate cutting other programs that do not so directly affect our security.
    Congratulations on the graphs and explanations! Your cleavages were explained very well, especially that of Men and Women. I find it very interesting that you explain this through the idea of girls seeing issues on more of a "spectrum" as opposed to starkly different, black and white options.
    Polling definitely tells us a lot about human nature and opinions on issues; thanks for a quality poll.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Nice job on the preject first off. Secondly, it is shocking how most students in general say that education is important, but most also say that Arizona has enough funding going towards it. This indeed is very contradictory if you look closely. Due to this I feel like most were compelled to say that education is very important due to morals and preconcieved notions instilled in them by parents and teachers that they do not actually possess themselves.
    And another suprising result from your poll, "where to cut funding". As Jessica said, a strongly conservative state, such as Arizona, which values personal protection and security over education would not be expected to come up with the results you did. An issue such as border security is very sensitive to our state's needs and the polls don't show that. On a biased basis, you can correlate the generally White, shelted, naive student population to overlook this as they live in a part of Arizona that is largely removed from illegal immigration. Were these students to live in central phoenix or tucson, along with many of our southern most cities, they most likely would have chosen this aspect differently.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Nice poll guys, the results for questions 1-3 between honors and gen ed kids are what I would expect them to be, honors students care about their education more than gen ed students, thats why they take on honors classes, they are also going to care about education more politically than gen ed student because the gen ed students don't care too much and they have other issues they are more interested in. The results for question 3 make sense too all students hear about from the news and teachers is how we keep cutting funding for education, so students who don't really have much of an opinion or who haven't researched current issues are probably more likely to assume that there inst enough money, due to what they have heard through others. What I really didn't expect was the results for number 4, I didn't expect people, especially students living in Arizona, to choose Border Security as the place we should cut the budget, I suppose its because all we ever hear about is increasing border security on the news; social and public services are really only covered at a national level in the media, so most students probably don't know much about them.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Excellent poll, guys. I am not really surprised that many students support education funding, especially among the Honors students. However, the result of one question that shocked and/or surprised me was question 4. The overall result for Question 4 surprised me the most because my group's project was on Immigration Reform, and the majority of students from our polls prefer deportation and the SB 1070. However the data from your poll portrays the opposite where students prefer to reduce border security financing to increase education financing.I believe that the reason for this is because your other options were too general compared to the option of 'border security.' I think you guys could have polled more accurately if you had either describe what the other options are or give examples of those options. For example, you can allude 'public services' to city maintenance or national defense.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Your polling questions were very simple! This is actually very good because the less students have to read, the more likely they are to think about their answers. I was very surprised at how many people said that education should not be a political issue; I think these are the very same people who felt education was only somewhat important. I was also surprised that so many students felt that money should be cut from border security to go into education. These results made me wonder a bit... did anyone ask you what "infrastructure" was? Do you think most people said money should be taken from Border Security because of the way they felt about immigration, the way they felt about education funding, or because they didn't understand the full impact of the others? I like the color scheme of your graphs, by the way. One more thing- you said you noticed that sophmores didn't fit the trend... Our group noticed that as well; maybe the sophmores are somehow less educated than the freshmen or conspired to ruin our polling results. :)

    ReplyDelete
  14. Interesting poll. I thought the results would be pretty self-explanatory, since everyone asked is a student and most students care about education enough to provide well-developed answers. However it seems like a pretty large margin of voters did not seem to care about education. Although no one thought education was unimportant, many thought that it was not an issue worthy of being a main issue in the country. I also found it highly surprising, especially for Arizona students, that most of the voters thought that taking money away from border security and sending it towards education reform would be the number one method of redirecting funds. Generally people living in Arizona tend to support border security spending.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Good job guys. I thought that it was very surprising that the majority of students polled on campus thought that the school recieved enough funding. With all the teachers bad-mouthing the district's cuts in funding, you would think that students would want more funding for their school. I know I do!

    You guys polled a much larger group of men compared to women and a much larger group of honors kids compared to general education. This may have skewed your results but I do not believe that it detracted from the poll to the point that would invalidate it.

    Finally, I thought that it made sense that honors kids would value their education and find it important. It also makes sense that those kids would want education to be a main political issue. Bravo guys!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Good job on the poll- the questions were well written, and the results make sense with what I would have expected. I did find it interesting that a large amount of students thought that yes, Arizona education had enough funding, considering all the talk from teachers about how funds are so low, and how essential getting the override passsed was. However, it makes more sense when one considers that we tend to be a conservative state that wouldn't necessarily support the taxes that would likely be required to get more funding, and most kids get a lot of their political ideas from their parents.
    The information on most students thinking money should be taken from border security was also interesting, considering how important the issue of illegal immigration has been for Arizona.
    All in all, it's an informative poll with some intriguing results. Good job!

    ReplyDelete
  17. Good job with the poll. I also really surprised that a lot of kids thought that the school recieved enough funding! It looked like a lot of students did not care about education all that much. I found it interesting that people would cut from border security to increase funding eventhough we live in Arizona( right at the border) It kinda showed that a majority of the students you surveyed were more liberal.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Nice job with the poll. I like that your questions were simple and to the point. That definitely must have helped eliminate any questions that people answering may have had.
    I was surprised with your results for quesiton 3. It's interesting that kids really think we receive enough funding. Have they not noticed that all of our classes are huge in comparison to those of other states'? I was also surprised that they thought we should decrease funding for border security to pay for education. Your results for question 1 were what I would have expected. Honors students do care more about their education than gen ed students. If they didn't they would have no motivation to take honors classes at all.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Great project! I just wonder, were there any differences between what minorities said in comparison to the majority? Or if people in clubs voted differently because they may know about the funding situation more? It made sense that honors students would appreciate schooling more because they are obviously more involved in the process, and that female students would care more about the liberal policies because they are generally more liberal than males. Overall great project, it really opens one's eyes to the subject

    ReplyDelete